On May 15, 2024, the Bureau of Criminal Investigation out of SP Lockport arrested Juliet McCarthy, 38 and Steven McCarthy, 39 both of Depew, NY for Enterprise Corruption (B Felony), Grand Larceny 2nd (C Felony), Grand Larceny 3rd (D Felony) and Conspiracy 5th (A Misdemeanor).
On April 24, 2024, Troopers out of SP Lockport had a walk-in complaint from Pony’s Irish Pub located at 23 Main Street in the village of Middleport in regards to two former employees were believed to have stolen cash and unprepared food from the business between 2020 and 2024. Investigation determined that both McCarthy’s worked together to routinely steal money and unprepared food from Pony’s Irish Pub in excess of $50,000.
Both suspects were processed without incident at SP Lockport and turned over to the Niagara County Sheriff’s Office to await CAP Court arraignment.
